Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies

Posted by Nick Sheridan on


What better way to celebrate PB + J day than a PB + J cookie recipe!

If you haven’t yet tried peanut butter and jam together… you are missing out!

It’s a match made in heaven and we have the perfect recipe for you to try out. It’s simple, only requires 4 ingredients and 8 minutes in the oven.



  • 1/2 cup Salted Natural Peanut butter (99th Monkey)
  • 1/4 cup maple syrup (or honey)
  • 1/4 cup flour (can use any flour)
  • 3 Strawberries


  • Microwave your strawberries for 15 seconds to soften them
  • Use a fork to mash them and put aside
  • Add honey, Peanut Butter and flour to a bowl and mix until combined and a dough consistency is reached
  • Roll into little balls (we made 10) and place onto a lined baking tray
  • Using your thumb, make imprints into the centre of each of the balls
  • Place the mashed strawberries into the centre of each of the biscuits
  • Place tray into the oven for 8 minutes at 180 degrees celsius

These are the perfect sweet treat to grab and go. The kids will love them, but so will the adults, as they’re not overly sweet.

The salt and creaminess of the Peanut Butter balances well with the sweet, yet slightly tart, taste of the strawberries.

We hope you enjoy them and if you make our PB and J cookies don’t forget to let us know your thoughts!

99th Monkey Almond butter Chocolate Clean coles supermarket Cookies Dessert Diet Easter Easter recipes Easy food Galentines Girls Night in Gluten Free Happiness Happy Healthy Healthy foods Healthy snacks Keto Lunch Macros Melbourne Natural nut butter Peanut butter Pistachio Protein Raspberry Recipes Simple recipes Snacks Treat Valentines Day Vegan

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment